optinmonster comparision
OPTINMONSTER ALTERNATIVE

OptinMonster Alternative: Popupsmart

We compared OptinMonster, a reputable popup solution, to Popupsmart based on what our readers care about the most. To help you decide, here's a reliable overview of how to measure between the two.

POPUPSMART
OPTINMONSTER

Suitability for Experts or Everyone

Popupsmart offers a straightforward and user-friendly interface, making it accessible for all skill levels. 

Its simplicity ensures that creating effective popups is easy for everyone, from beginners to seasoned marketers.

OptinMonster, while robust, tends to cater more to users with a bit more experience in digital marketing. 

Its comprehensive features are powerful but may require a deeper understanding to use them to their full potential.

popsupmart logoOptinmonster logo

Shopify Integration & Email Automation

Popupsmart’s no-code popup builder is equipped with email automation that connects directly to your Shopify store. 

This automation enables a seamless transition from capturing leads with forms and popups to nurturing them with personalized emails, all without needing any coding knowledge.

While it offers dynamic popup software, OptinMonster does not include native email automation. 

This means that additional tools and manual setup may be required for those looking to create a more automated marketing strategy.

popsupmart logoOptinmonster logo

Popup Design Templates

Popupsmart has an impressive selection of 300+ modern and conversion-focused popup designs, including custom templates for Shopify.

OptinMonster only offers a bit more than 100 templates. These templates are functional and versatile but may not offer the same level of uniqueness and conversion optimization as Popupsmart's offerings.

popsupmart logoOptinmonster logo

Free Plan & Trial

Popupsmart offers a permanent free plan that includes 5,000 page views, which is suitable for those just starting out or with limited traffic needs.

OptinMonster does not have a free plan, which means users must choose a paid plan after their initial payment, starting from $16/month for the Basic plan.

popsupmart logoOptinmonster logo

Popup Creation Ease

Popupsmart simplifies the popup creation experience with four focused campaign types: Lightbox, Sidebar, Full Screen, and Floating Bar popups

Understanding that effective popups are an extension of a website’s marketing strategy, not a design afterthought, Popupsmart offers conversion-optimized templates.

OptinMonster provides a broader range of popup types, including Inline Forms and Content Lockers, catering to various marketing strategies. 

Their drag-and-drop builder offers flexibility but can be more complex, potentially requiring more experienced users to leverage its full potential.

popsupmart logoOptinmonster logo

Multi-Site Management

Popupsmart scales up the number of websites you can use with each plan, reaching up to seven websites on the Expert plan. This offers better scalability for users with multiple websites.

OptinMonster limits users to a maximum of five websites even on its Growth plan, which may restrict users with more extensive needs.

popsupmart logoOptinmonster logo

No Teaser Feature

Popupsmart offers having a teaser popup for each of your campaigns. Teaser popups are a mini-size representation of the main popup campaign. It absolutely does not bother users, it opens the main popup campaign when clicked.

Optinmonster has no teaser feature, unfortunately. For this reason, popups can be annoying to website visitors. With Teaser, you can completely eliminate this situation.

popsupmart logoOptinmonster logo

Popupsmart vs Optinmonster

Price
plus icon
Pricing per 100.000 Page Views
$57.5
$49
Free Plan
table yes icon
table no icon
Unlimited Popup Campaign
table yes icon
table yes icon
15-Day Money-Back Guarantee
table yes icon
table yes icon
Campaigns
plus icon
Announcement Popups
table yes icon
table yes icon
Email Collection Popups
table yes icon
table yes icon
Coupon Popups
table yes icon
table yes icon
Cookie Consent Popups
table yes icon
table no icon
Recommendation Popups
table yes icon
table yes icon
Abandonment Cart Reminder Popups
table yes icon
table yes icon
Phone Call Campaigns
table yes icon
table no icon
Gamification Popups
table yes icon
table yes icon
Design and Creation
plus icon
5 Minute Popup Campaign Creation
table yes icon
table no icon
+350 Popup Designs
table yes icon
table no icon
Advanced Form Builder
table yes icon
table yes icon
GDPR Ready
table yes icon
table yes icon
Success Popup Feature
table yes icon
table yes icon
Teaser Popup Feature
table yes icon
table yes icon
Custom CSS
table yes icon
table yes icon
Custom Fonts
table yes icon
table yes icon
Display Effects
table yes icon
table yes icon
Email Notifications
table yes icon
table no icon
Targeting
plus icon
Geo Location Targeting
table yes icon
table yes icon
After X Seconds
table yes icon
table yes icon
On Exit-Intent
table yes icon
table yes icon
On Exit-Intent on mobile
table yes icon
table yes icon
In Activity Sensor
table yes icon
table yes icon
After Scrolling Down
table yes icon
table yes icon
Browsing Spesific Pages
table yes icon
table yes icon
New vs Returning
table yes icon
table yes icon
Traffic Sources (Facebook, Instagram, Adwords)
table yes icon
table yes icon
Cookie Targeting
table yes icon
table yes icon
HTML Source Targeting
table yes icon
table no icon
Campaign Scheduling
table yes icon
table no icon
Operational System
table yes icon
table no icon
Browser Language
table yes icon
table yes icon
On-Click Targeting
table yes icon
table yes icon
Popup Frequency Settings
table yes icon
table yes icon
Integration
plus icon
Mailchimp
table yes icon
table yes icon
Mailerlite
table yes icon
table yes icon
Sendgrid
table yes icon
table no icon
Sendloop
table yes icon
table yes icon
Webhook
table yes icon
table no icon
Sendinblue
table yes icon
table yes icon
Hubspot
table yes icon
table yes icon
Salesforce
table no icon
table yes icon
Zapier
table yes icon
table yes icon
Email Marketing & CRMs (via zapier)
table yes icon
table yes icon
Website Builders & CMSs
table yes icon
table yes icon
eCommerce Platforms
table yes icon
table yes icon
Analytics
plus icon
Live Conversion Analytics
table yes icon
table yes icon
Google Analytics Event Integration
table yes icon
table no icon
Support & Security and SEO
plus icon
E-Mail Support
table yes icon
table yes icon
Priority Customer Support
table yes icon
table no icon
Dedicated Success Manager
table yes icon
table no icon
%99.99 Uptime
table yes icon
table yes icon
GDPR Complaint
table yes icon
table yes icon
SEO and Google Compliance
table yes icon
table yes icon

FAQ

Which tool allows you to create more appealing popups to website visitors?
plus icon
Popups that don't consider user experience can be annoying. This is where Popupsmart stands out. Unlike Optinmonster, Popupsmart offers a special "teaser" feature. This allows you to show a smaller version of your main popup. It only opens fully when a visitor chooses to click on it. This makes popups less intrusive and more user-friendly. 
Is there a free plan in both Popupsmart and Optinmonster?
plus icon
Optinmonster does not have a free plan. They offer a free trial instead which asks for credit card information. Popupsmart, on the other hand, provides a free plan which you keep forever until your site reaches 5.000 page-views. Additionally, you do not have to enter your credit card information for the free plan.
Which one is better Popupsmart’s basic plan or Optinmonster’s plus plan?
plus icon
Popupsmart's basic plan at $32.50/month offers substantial value with 50,000 page views, usable on three websites, and includes 1,000 emails and unlimited popups. OptinMonster's cheaper $9/month plan is limited to 2,500 page views on a single site, which is potentially restrictive for growing businesses.
Can I create gamification popups with both popup builder tools?
plus icon
Yes, both Popupsmart and OptinMonster have gamification features. However, OptinMonster allows coupon wheel campaigns only for the $49 growth plan. Popupsmart provides wheel (gamification) popups for all plans except the free plan. With Popupsmart, you can convert more visitors into customers with gamification by paying only $32.5.
Do both Popupsmart and OptiMonster provide phone call popups?
plus icon
OptinMonster does not have a phone call popup option. So, OptinMonster users cannot increase their phone call traffic. They would need to purchase another 3rd party tool which is inconvenient. Popupsmart provides phone call popups that increase phone call traffic as a campaign goal. You can efficiently increase your phone call traffic along with other business solutions with a single tool.
Which tool has the upper hand in advanced targeting options?
plus icon
Although both popup builder tools have advanced targeting options, Popupsmart has the upper hand. Differently from OptinMonster, Popupsmart has the cookie targeting feature which allows users to display popups only to registered users or unregistered ones. Moreover, Popupsmart provides the campaign scheduling option which enables users to schedule popup campaigns between certain dates.
Which tool has more business solutions?
plus icon
Popupsmart holds the advantage regarding the range of business solutions offered. Compared to OptinMonster's three campaign solutions - growing your email list, reducing cart abandonment, and increasing sales conversions - Popupsmart has a wider selection with 12 solutions. These include Increase Sales Conversion, Reduce Cart Abandonment, Promote Product & Offers, Collect Form Submission, Get More Phone Calls, Gamify Your Campaign, Collect Feedback & Surveys, and more... 

OptinMonster Alternative Popup Builder Tools

optinmonster comparision

Popupsmart vs Optinmonster

Sleeknote Alternative: Popupsmart

Popupsmart vs Sleeknote

Popupsmart vs Optimonk

Popupsmart vs Optimonk

Popupsmart vs Ninja Popup

Popupsmart vs Ninja Popup

Popupsmart vs Adoric

Popupsmart vs Adoric

Popupsmart vs Mailmunch

Popupsmart vs Mailmunch

Popupsmart vs Poptin

Popupsmart vs Poptin

Popupsmart vs Hello bar

Popupsmart vs Hello bar

Popupsmart vs Privy

Popupsmart vs Privy

Popupsmart vs Sumo

Popupsmart vs Sumo

Popupsmart vs Wisepops

Popupsmart vs Wisepops

5 Best OptinMonster Alternatives 2024

Optinmonster alternative

OptinMonster is a recognized tool for enhancing conversion rates. However, its high cost and complex features might seem overwhelming, especially if you're operating on a budget or looking for a more user-friendly alternative.

This complexity adds to its learning curve, which might deter you from seeking more straightforward tools. But worry not; an extensive list of cost-effective and simpler alternatives to OptinMonster is available.

1. Popupsmart vs OptinMonster

Popupsmart Cover

Popupsmart is a powerful, code-free, and user-friendly popup builder with converting email automation designed to help businesses of all sizes increase conversions, grow their email lists, and effectively engage with their audiences.

When it comes to enhancing your online presence and boosting conversions, Popupsmart offers a suite of advantages that make it the standout choice over OptinMonster.

Pricing: Popupsmart offers a free plan and wallet-friendly paid options. The Basic Plan costs $32.5/month for 50,000 views on three websites. In contrast, OptinMonster's similar plan offers less value for your money.

Ease of Use: Popupsmart stands out with its simple interface, which allows anyone to create impactful popups in no time, while OptinMonster might be a bit complex for beginners.

Shopify Compatibility: Popupsmart provides exclusive features for Shopify, like email automation, product syncing, and effective targeting. OptinMonster, while offering robust popup tools, doesn't provide these e-commerce-centric options.

E-commerce Features: Popupsmart offers tools specifically designed for engaging e-commerce customers, ranging from cart abandonment solutions to special offers for big spenders.

Targeting and Segmentation: While OptinMonster offers geo-location and exit-intent triggers, Popupsmart goes further with Shopify-specific targeting, engaging email and SMS campaigns, and AI-backed smart targeting, ensuring your campaigns are as effective as possible.

2. Ninja Popup vs OptinMonster

ninjapopups vs optionmonster

Ninja Popup is a WordPress plugin that enables you to create popups with customized content for your website. The plugin includes features such as newsletter subscription popups, follow buttons for social media sites, and recommended or related items on your site.

Pricing: Ninja Popups costs $24, While OptinMonster costs $9 for a basic plan, which allows 2,500 Pageviews and only 1 website.

General: Ninja Popups is a WordPress plugin that is compatible with WordPress and WooCommerce. It’s affordable, easy to use, and only takes minutes to set up when compared to OptinMonster. Ninja Popups has fewer targeting options than OptinMonster.You can use Ninja Popup for a one-time fee of $24, while OptinMonster bills you monthly. Plugins may cause websites to slow down. They require updates and may lower UX.

3. Icegram vs OptinMonster

icegram vs optionmonster

Icegram is also a WordPress plugin for onsite lead generation, calls to action and conversion optimization. It has several useful features that make capturing leads and converting them into sales easy. 

Pricing: Unlike OptinMonster, Icegram provides a free plan. If you decide to upgrade, Icegram's Pro plan costs $97 per year, including a license for one website and features not available in the free plan. Icegram also offers a lifetime subscription for $249. On the other hand, for a monthly OptinMonster subscription, you'd have to pay $9 for the basic plan, which only allows for 2,500 pageviews.

General: Icegram focuses on creating popups to help grow your email list. It is more affordable than OptinMonster but mainly targets email marketing. On the other hand, OptinMonster offers a wider range of features but comes with a higher price tag.

4. Getsitecontrol vs OptinMonster

getsitecontrol vs optionmonster

Getsitecontrol is a website-building tool for small businesses that makes it easy for you to create popups. It’s designed for people who want to maximize their conversions without knowing how to code. Some of its main features are:

Pricing: Getsitecontrol offers a 7-day free trial and fully inclusive plans, meaning all features, integrations, and templates come as standard, regardless of the plan. The most basic plan provides 20,000 monthly widget views, starting at $9. The key difference to consider is that many of OptinMonster's features come with an additional cost, making the overall price higher depending on the monthly plan you choose.

General: Getsitecontrol is a great alternative to OptinMonster. It has some slightly different features, but the quality of both is similar. Getsitecontrol is cheaper than OptinMonster.

5. Thrive Leads vs OptinMonster

thrivesuite vs optionmonster

Thrive Leads is a lead generation plugin for WordPress. It has targeting options and comes with an easy-to-use A/B testing feature. You can also hide forms or show different offers to your existing subscribers with SmartLinks.

Pricing: Thrive Leads is part of the Thrive Suite, and Thrive Suite is $90 quarterly, meaning 30 dollars monthly. However, you can’t buy an individual plugin. 

General: Thrive Suite's standard annual pricing for WordPress site tools is $599, offering a suite of plugins, a theme builder, and the ability to use on up to five websites. OptinMonster's pricing ranges from $9 to $49 per month (billed annually), with tiered plans catering to different page views and site usage levels. Thrive Suite is priced as an all-in-one package, while OptinMonster scales its features and pricing based on usage and growth potential.